(1) Homa,Seth - Dowling,John [B06]
Notes by John Dowling



1.e4 g6 2.d4 Bg7 3.Nc3 d6 4.Nf3 a6 5.Be2


This move is given an ! by GM Tiger Hillarp Persson in his 2005 book titled "Tiger's Modern." Strangely, this move isn't even mentioned by ECO. ECO only gives 5. Bd3, 5. a4, and 5. a3.

5...b5 6.a4


This move is not mentioned by Tiger but instead he follows the game Khalifman-Popov, St. Petersburg 1997, which continued 6.0-0 Nd7 7.Re1 c5 8.Bg5 Bb7 and now 9.a4! This suggests that a4 is a good idea, but may be better after White develops first. Khalifman went on to win but Tiger suggests some improvements for Black later on in the game which may have improved Black's chances.

6...b4 7.Nd5 Bb7


I thought that this was a good move at the time and I don't think it is a bad move, but a search of my database showed that the stronger players (such as Larry Christiansen and Maurice Ashley) both responded here with 7...a5

8.Nxb4


A recent game went instead 8.Bc4 e6 9.Nxb4 a5 10.Nd3 Bxe4 and Black went on to win in Taple-Leon Hoyos, Mexican Open 2007.

8...Bxe4 9.0-0 a5 10.Na2


10.Nd3 seemed like a very logical move, controlling some nice central squares. But Seth has another idea in mind.

10...Nf6 11.Bd2


Targeting my somewhat weak a-pawn. I was actually more concerned about 11.c4 and then Nc3.

11...0-0 12.Nc1


Continuing with the idea of attacking the isolated a-pawn. But this pawn can be defended and this maneuvering is taking a lot of time, allowing Black to counter in the center.

12...Nfd7


I thought the knight configuration on d7 and c6 was better than d7 and f6. Also, my dark-squared bishop becomes uncovered.

13.Nb3 c5 14.Bc3 Nc6 15.dxc5


Somewhat of a surprise. I was expecting 15.Qd2 and after 15...Qb6 I was thinkin g the position was fairly even. Now, however, I think Black has the better chances.

15...Bxc3 16.bxc3 Nxc5 17.Ng5 Bf5 18.Bf3 Nxb3


It seems strange for Black to straighten out White's pawns, but I though White's new pawn configuration would actually be easier to attack with Black getting the nice half-opened b- and c-files. The alternative 18...Qc7 seemed OK, but the move I chose looked easier to play.

19.cxb3 Rc8 20.Qd2 Qb6 21.Bd5 e6 22.Bxc6


Probably more testing was 22.Be4 Qxb3 23.Qxd6 h6 but Black still seems to be on top.

22...Rxc6 23.b4 Rfc8 24.Rad1


After a long thought Seth played this totally unexpected move. I assume he just didn't want to subject himself to defending thepositionafter 24.Ra3 Rc4 25.bxa5 Qc5

24...d5


I really didn't spend much time on this natural-looking move. 24...Rxc3 25.bxa5 looked OK for Black, but this looked better to me.

25.h3


I don't think White has time for this move. White may be trying to trap my bishop, but I will always have the c2 square. I was more concerned about 25.Nf3 Rxc3 26.bxa5 Qxa5 27.Rc1 when I wasn't sure how I was going to proceed. However, looking at it now it looks like 27...Bd3 28.Rfe1 Qc5 is a simple enough plan to keep the edge.

25...Rxc3 26.bxa5 Qxa5 27.Qd4 Qd8


This move is fine, but I missed that 27...h6 28.Nf3 Bxh3 was possible.

28.Qh4 h5 29.Rd4 e5 30.Rb4 R8c4 31.Rxc4 Rxc4 32.Qg3 Rxa4


Here again there is a cute trick against the knight that I missed. After 32...h4 33.Qe3 e4! traps the knight with f6 to follow.

33.Rd1 f6 34.Qb3 Ra5 35.Nf3 Kg7


This move is too cautious. I should have played 35...Qc7 to seize the c-file and cover the 7th rank.

36.Rc1 Ra7 37.Nh4 Be6 38.Rc6 Bf7 39.Qg3 Qd7 40.Rd6 Qc8 41.Kh2 Ra1


with the idea of Qc1 and a mating attack.

42.Qf3 Be6 43.Qb3 g5 44.Qb6 gxh4


A bad move. Seth showed me right after the game that 44...Qc1 won on the spot.

45.Rc6


I missed this zwischenzug. Now I have to find a series of best moves to hold the win.

45...Rb1 46.Qa7+ Rb7 47.Qa6 Rc7 48.Rxe6 Qxa6 49.Rxa6 Rd7


Black manages to win this endgame (although in the next round I found out against Atulya Shetty that being two pawns up in a rook ending is not necessarily an easy win for me!)

50.Kg1 d4 51.Kf1 Kg6 52.Ke2 Kf5 53.Ra8 d3+ 54.Kd2 e4 55.Rh8 Kg6 56.Re8 f5 57.Rf8 Rf7 58.Rd8 Rg7 59.Ke3 Kf7 60.Kf4 Ke7 61.Ra8 d2 62.Ra1 Ke6 63.Rd1 Rd7 64.Ke3 Ke5 65.f4+ Ke6 66.Kf2 Rd3 67.Kf1 Kd5 68.Ke2 Kd4 69.Kf2 Kc3 70.Kf1 Kc2 71.Ke2 Re3+

0-1